read the news // live the culture

Album review: Nada Surf – The Stars Are Indifferent To Astronomy

  Friday 13th January 2012

After dalliances with the mainstream and major label disputes in the mid-nineties, alt rock three-piece Nada Surf have experienced a creative renaissance recently, recast as unsung cult icons.

Nada Surf's new album
Nada Surf’s new album

Their sixth studio album, released on City Slang Records to minimal fanfare takes its title from a phrase beloved of singer Matthew Caws’ father. In a sense, it serves as a neat summary of the band’s situation in their 18th year.

They are seemingly indifferent to their standing in the rock canon – an unthinkable attitude during the days of their arch, proto-hipster anthem “Popular” – yet they are making some of the best music of their career, perhaps as a direct result.

The songs on display here are pure panoramic pop, such as a more carefree Foo Fighters and some “Free All Angels” (Ash). There’s even a hint of Phoenix’s Gallic insouciance in the effortless melodies and arrangements. Singer-guitarist Caws may not have the strongest voice but his wide-eyed delivery and exuberance manages to sell even the most standard power-pop arrangement. The band have alluded to their desire to capture on record the enthusiasm whipped up when playing a new song together for the first time and nowhere is this more apparent than on blistering opener “Clear Eye Clouded Mind”.

Elsewhere, first single “When I Was Young” starts off as an acoustic number reminiscent of Big Star or the Go-Betweens, before teetering into a full-blown shoegaze epic, Caws repeating “what was that world I was dreaming of?” in a bittersweet ode to more innocent times.

After such a fantastic start, the album inevitably starts to flag around the midway point. Apart from the surprise trumpet clarion on the lounge-y “Let The Fight Do The Fighting”, the instrumentals hardly stray from the standard rock set-up, inducing involuntary listener fatigue. It’s all very stirring and generally pleasant – and “Teenage Dreams” is a line I think we can all get behind. It’s not until the final track “The Future” that Nada Surf scale the heights of the first few tracks, ending on a definite high.

A solid, occasionally spectacular outing which sanctions their status as rock outsiders – probably their best effort since their masterpiece “Let Go” – you get the feeling they wouldn’t have it any other way.

Verdict: ••••

Freddy Powys

Listen to lead single “When I Was Young” here


  Log in  

More about the author


Read more from...

Share this story

  • Pin It
  • Share on Google+
  • Reddit
  • Stumble
  • LinkedIn

Latest articles

Frieze Videos showcase at the Institute of Contemporary Arts
Frieze Videos showcase at the Institute of Contemporary Arts

As part of Frieze’s commitment to being what co-editor Jennifer Higgie describes as “more than just pages [read more]

Rodin at the London Coliseum | Dance review
Rodin at the London Coliseum

St Petersberg’s Eifmann ballet is in town to showcase two performances: Anna Karenina and Rodin, of which the latter [read more]

Cut Copy and RÜFÜS at The Forum | Live review
Cut Copy and RÜFÜS at The Forum

It was all about the EDM at The Forum last night, as Cut Copy played their last UK date on a whirlwind world tour, [read more]

Cool Rider at the Duchess | Theatre review
Cool Rider at the Duchess

Running for only seven nights at the Duchess Theatre, Cool Rider is a sassy, rugged and surprisingly raunchy adaptation [read more]

Elbow at the O2 Arena | Live review
Elbow at the O2 Arena

Elbow are a remarkable band. Armed with some fantastic new songs from their latest album The Take Off and Landing of [read more]