read the news // live the culture

Film review: Song for Marion

  Monday 18th February 2013

Gemma Arterton is quickly becoming the go-to-girl for Hollywood producers who need to fill a space with a pretty face. Her eye candy roles in blockbuster films Clash of the Titans and Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time have allowed her name to become familiar on the US circuit. Arterton currently has five films in production, beginning with the hotly anticipated Hansel & Gretel Witch Hunters alongside Jeremy Renner (Gretel) due for release in January of next year. As with Keira Knightley’s transition to the US, Arterton’s sweet nature and innocence seem to remain in the UK as she stars in another middle-of-the-road comedy which, unsurprisingly, is all about the journey of (that overused phrase) self-discovery.

marionSong for Marion centres on elderly grump Arthur (Terrance Stamp) and his wife Marion (Vanessa Redgrave), who is suffering from the late stages of cancer. To fill her days, Marion is part of an OAP choir run by Elizabeth (Arterton), which rehearses at her local community centre. Arthur supports his wife but struggles to connect with her emotionally. His strained relationship with his son James (Christopher Eccleston) doesn’t help matters much either.

It’s a different tack for director and writer Paul Andrew Williams who has previously made some violent British horrors such as Cherry Tree Lane and The Cottage. There isn’t much to shout about here and the pay cheque was probably the only incentive to make this picture.

Redgrave clearly owns her role and overshadows the other three in the first half, which is all about her cancer battle. As the focus of the narrative shifts to Arthur and his involvement with the choir, the film gains some substance and steps up a level. However, the difference is only very slight as the tone of the film continues to be drab. The humour revolves primarily around the group of elderly people singing incongruous pop classics like Let’s Talk About Sex – hilarious. If you anticipate better from the actors, Song for Marion will remain unsatisfactory. The “aww, look at the old people trying to be normal,” factor gets incredibly tiresome and is a running gag throughout the film.

Song for Marion is predictable and boring. It managed to muster two, maybe three laughs for the 90 minutes’ running time and, with the level of talent on offer, we expected a lot more.

Verdict: ●●

Richard Taverner

 Watch the trailer for Song for Marion here

More about the author


Share this story


  • Pin It
  • Share on Google+
  • Reddit
  • Stumble
  • LinkedIn

Latest related

Sex Tape | Movie review
Sex Tape

Long before Kim Kardashian and Paris Hilton were caught out, even before Pamela Anderson cavorted with Tommy Lee, Rob [read more]

Vancouver Sleep Clinic at the Ace Hotel | Live review
Vancouver Sleep Clinic at the Ace Hotel

The words “teen sensation” often invite negative connotations – think Justin Bieber, Miley Cyrus, Connor [read more]

Million Dollar Arm| Movie review
Million Dollar Arm

Walt Disney takes this remarkable true story and turns it into an uplifting baseball tale slapped with a sickly sweet [read more]

Madame X at the Arcola | Opera review
Madame X at the Arcola | Opera review

Arcola Theatre’s Grimeborn series sees Tim Benjamin’s new opera Madame X take to the stage for a performance [read more]

Photo sharing service Instagram launches new time-lapse app Hyperlapse
Photo sharing service Instagram launches new time-lapse app Hyperlapse

The US social media firm Instagram has introduced a new time-lapse app called Hyperlapse. The app has in-built [read more]

Archives