Film festivals Sundance London

First Reformed

Sundance London 2018: First Reformed | Review

Paul Schrader’s latest film takes after others in his screenwriting repertoire – including Taxi Driver and Raging Bull – in being a close-up look at a tumultuous character. In the director’s chair, the American proves that he can combine this sensitivity for the written word with a profound grasp of the visual. 

First Reformed charts the trials and tribulations of pastor Toller (Ethan Hawke) in the period leading up to the reconsecration of his parish church. As his house of prayer receives a new lick of paint, the protagonist himself suffers his own decomposing interior. The feature recalls Bergman’s Winter Light, no doubt a great companion piece about faith being tested in troubled times. 

This is a movie told by faces. Close up images of Hawke and his castmates in lengthy conversations are mesmerising. This severe style suits the austerity of the churches, granting much of the picture a chilling sobriety. Schrader, as ever, delivers a finely composed script. Toller’s diary entries, his musings on God and the imposing edifice of his parish build the character’s complexity beautifully. 

There are few clichés here, with a great deal of incidental music stripped away. Hawke is the constant focus of the audience’s attention. This is a weighty performance by the actor: quiet, considered and deeply powerful. He simmers and boils with the same strength and commitment that will not have you always liking Toller, but perpetually wanting to love him. 

Where this film teeters a little is in some questionable incongruities and directorial choices. Had it kept its understatement throughout, First Reformed – the movie and its message alike – would have been strengthened. Still, the feature addresses social and environmental issues in a timely manner with an empathic call for a resurgent humanity. First and foremost, however, this work of cinema is a titanic character study that will sit comfortably among Schrader’s other achievements.

Daniel Amir

First Reformed is released nationwide on 13th July 2018.

For further information about Sundance 2018 visit here.

Read more reviews from the festival here.

Watch the trailer for First Reformed here:

More in Film festivals

“It’s really complicated. It’s really hard if you put yourself in his shoes”: Nawaf Al Dhufairi, Raghad Bokhari and Lana Komsany on Hijra at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“Why didn’t I raise my voice for the Rohingya people?”: Akio Fujimoto on Lost Land at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“When you live with someone with a harsh mental illness, you can really sink with them”: Zain Duraie and Alaa Alasad on Sink at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“It felt quite absurd to be part of that social jungle”: Sara Balghonaim on Irtizaz at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

Red Sea International Film Festival 2025: Highlights and interviews with Juliette Binoche, Shigeru Umebayashi, Sir Anthony Hopkins, Idris Elba, and More

Laura Della Corte

“All that matters, I think, is the partnership”: Amira Diab on Wedding Rehearsal at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“Modern love – it’s a bit dark”: Anas Ba Tahaf and Sarah Taibah on A Matter of Life and Death at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“I believe inside each human being there is an artist”: Mohamed Jabarah Al-Daradji, Hussein Raad Zuwayr and Samar Kazem Jawad on Irkalla – Gilgamesh Dream

Laura Della Corte

“When you try to forget the trauma without fixing it, it will never leave”: Yanis Koussim on Roqia at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte