Cinema & TVMovie reviews

A Talent for Murder

Sincere, stylish and supported by some brilliant acting

By Umar Ali

Share this story

A Talent for Murder | Movie review

A Talent for Murder
A Talent for Murder

Based on Joanna Murray-Smith’s 2014 play Switzerland, and the first narrative feature from director Anton Corbijn in 11 years, A Talent for Murder stars Helen Mirren as author Patricia Highsmith, who is approached in her Swiss home by upstart editor Edward (Alden Ehrenreich), who appeals to the misanthropic and reclusive writer to pen one more Ripley novel. She is initially reluctant, but eventually agrees to give Edward his manuscript on the condition that he helps pen the final murder; the creative process brings out new sides to writer and editor, and the lines between fiction and reality begin to blur.

Adapted from a two-character play, the film’s narrative focuses on the ever-changing relationship between Edward and Patricia. Mirren and Ehrenreich are fantastic counterparts, reflecting the shifting power dynamics through their performances; Highsmith starts by projecting a confident, cynical (and occasionally sinister) persona that eventually gives way to reveal deep vulnerability, while Edward’s initial youthful awkwardness gradually shifts to reveal an unexpected inner darkness. While it could have benefited from showing more of this compelling dynamic, what is on screen is thoroughly entertaining.

A Talent for Murder also benefits from a strong script; Mirren took on the project because the screenplay was a “page-turner”, and the final piece takes the audience on a thrilling ride with plenty of twists and turns, as well as some interesting examinations of the creative process and the nature of fiction itself.

It’s a story about storytelling, and the metafictional layers are compelling, but the movie also seems reluctant to dive as deeply into its themes as it could have, making the attempted gut-punches feel somewhat pulled. The fictional final Ripley novel that Edward and Patricia come up with also feels substantially less interesting than the dynamic the two characters share, which blunts the feature’s messaging and slightly deflates the piece’s momentum – it also takes away from the time that Mirren and Ehrenreich spend on screen swapping barbs, not giving much in return.

Still, A Talent for Murder is for the most part an enjoyable experience, and a great comeback for Corbijn. It doesn’t quite stick the landing in every aspect, and its structure is a little wonky at times, but it’s sincere, stylish and supported by some brilliant acting. It could have done with a bit more bite, a sharper and deadlier sting in its tale, but it’s still fun.

Umar Ali

A Talent for Murder is released nationwide on 20th November 2026.

Watch the trailer for A Talent for Murder here: