Surveillance powers: Should the police have right of access to journalists’ files?
In a year that has already seen press freedom challenged from all sides, controversy has now surrounded the right of authorities to access journalists’ sources.
David Cameron has accepted recommendations for police to require “judicial oversight” when seeking communications data to identify journalists’ sources.
But less than two months after the attacks on Charlie Hebdo brought journalistic liberties to the forefront of world news, is further state regulation – no matter whom it favours – a step backwards?
An inquiry by the Interception of Communications Commissioner’s Office (IOCCO) found that in the last three years, 19 police forces made more than 600 applications for access to confidential sources. In the same period, police sought communications data on 82 journalists and 233 of 242 suspected sources.
Interception of Communication commissioner Sir Anthony May recommended to the PM that police obtain judicial authorisation when seeking communications data to identify a journalistic source, stating that the police had not given “due consideration to Article 10” (freedom of expression).
“The need to protect the confidentiality of journalistic sources is crucial to safeguard the free press in a democratic society,” May said.
May criticised the current and draft codes of practice for failing to provide enough guidance on police powers. New legislation would also be required after the expiry of the Data Retention and Investigatory Powers Act 2014 (DRIPA) at the end of 2016.
After January’s backlash from the Paris attacks saw many calling for state-sanctioned censorship, it is easy to see May’s “free press” alongside “new legislation” as no less than a surrender.
While the inquiry highlighted the threat of a “chilling effect” on freedom of expression, the fault lies not in the existing regulations but in the will of police and officials to exploit press confidentiality.
Laws such as the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, which many news organisations have accused authorities of attempting to circumvent, seem redundant when posed against investigators that are willing to twist journalistic liberties to their advantage.
Assistant chief constable Richard Berry, who leads the police in intercepting communications data, maintained that he was committed to implementing the law according to its own guidelines.
“To that end, we announced our plans for a board of communications data ethics to consider issues of public concern in an increasingly digitised world,” he said.
The Association of Chief Police Officers avoided accusations of suppressing press freedom, instead citing the responsibility of both police forces and news agencies to target corrupt relationships between reporters and authorities.
Perhaps, in the face of threats to human liberties and expression, the answer is not to further jeopardise these freedoms with flagrant lawmaking, but for the police and agencies to agree that source confidentiality is more than a legal matter.
In the wake of Charlie Hebdo and subsequent shootings at Krudttønden cultural centre in Copenhagen, which still lie fresh in our minds, we should endeavour to observe press freedom in practice rather than merely in theory, and treat journalism and crime-prevention as the disparate entities that they are.
Thomas Rhys Jones
- 1
A Talent for Murder
Umar Ali
- 2
Noah Kahan at the O2 Arena
Katherine Parry
- 3
Giant – The Play
Natallia Pearmain
- 4
- 5
You Can See Everything
Guy Lambert
Filipiñana
Andrew Murray
A Talent for Murder
Umar Ali
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping
Antonia Georgiou
You Can See Everything
Guy Lambert
Skye Newman at Brixton Academy
Tallulah Allen











