Culture Cinema & Tv Movie reviews

A Promise

A Promise | Movie review

A Promise is an adaptation of Sefan Zweig’s novel Journey into the Past (Widerstand der Wirklichkeit). The picture tells a complicated love story that tackles the challenge of long-term, long-distance separation in early 20th-century Germany.

Friedrich, a graduate of humble origins (Richard Madden), takes up a clerical post in a steel factory. Impressed by his work, the elderly owner Karl (Alan Rickman) takes him on as his private secretary. Karl is confined to his home due to his declining health, and the young man moves in to continue his work. There he meets the owner’s wife, Lotte (Rebecca Hall), a much younger woman, beautiful and reserved.

As time passes Friedrich falls passionately in love with Lotte but does not dare reveal his feelings. A romantic intrigue develops in this stifling bourgeois home, all looks and silences, without a single word or gesture of love.

French director Patrice Leconte adapted the story and for the first time makes a movie in English. A Promise is a classic romance enriched by modern camera movements – Leconte is the camera operator himself, one of very few directors to take on this role. With his oblique approach to direction, he gives a contemporary interpretation to very classic characters.

Even though the script is dull and uneventful at times, the strong acting and direction make the film worth watching till the end.

Filippo L’Astorina, the Editor

A Promise is released nationwide on 1st August 2014 and on VOD on 4th August.

More in Movie reviews

A Big Bold Beautiful Journey

Antonia Georgiou

Tape

Andrew Murray

Happyend

Christina Yang

Toronto International Film Festival 2025: California Schemin’

Selina Sondermann

The Long Walk

Selina Sondermann

From Ground Zero

Andrew Murray

Islands

Selina Sondermann

Downton Abbey: The Grand Finale

Ezelle Alblas

Toronto International Film Festival 2025: Christy

Selina Sondermann