Film festivals London Film Festival 2016

I Am Not a Serial Killer

London Film Festival 2016: I Am Not a Serial Killer | Review

In a northern Minnesota town a killer lurks, and 16-year-old John Wayne Cleaver (a character with three names, as with several famous murderers) wants to find him. A kind of Back to the Future meets The Silence of the Lambs, Billy O’Brien and Christopher Hyde’s I Am Not a Serial Killer is a unique and intriguing thriller.

Diagnosed by his psychiatrist as a sociopath, John (Max Records) wonders whether or not he might have homicidal tendencies, and as such, helping to prepare the corpses at his family’s morgue might not be the best idea. Whether John is actually potentially a serial killer himself or just an ideal candidate for the FBI due to his fascination with them is never completely certain. Obsessed with finding the homicidal maniac terrorising his town, he follows a young suspect, only to find that the true perpetrator is someone completely unexpected.

A loner who sees few people besides his mother (Laura Fraser) and aunt (Christina Baldwin), John has created self-imposed rules to curb his murderous impulses, and forces himself to spend time with his “friend” Max (Raymond Barnstorm) to pass as normal. His only other friend is Mr Crowley (Christopher Lloyd) next door. It is after John discovers the killer’s identity that he doggedly follows him, then becoming bolder, tries to thwart him. But what he is confronting is more horrific than he could imagine.

Cinematographer Robbie Ryan shoots some gorgeous grainy shots of a Minnesota suburb in winter, creating incongruence between normal suburbia and the gruesome slaughters, as well as an ambience of icy creepiness. Max Records brilliantly plays John as a teen who is an innocent but also devoid of emotion. Known for his role in Where the Wild Things Are, he has grown up to become an accomplished actor. Christopher Lloyd (Back to the Future) is as usual a remarkable performer, but here he takes on a new dimension in character and is fiercely impressive.

A riveting, well-put-together, well-acted piece, I Am Not a Serial Killer is terrifying, compelling and highly entertaining.

Catherine Sedgwick

I Am Not a Serial Killer is released nationwide on 9th December 2016.

For further information about the 60th London Film Festival visit here.

Read more reviews from the festival here.

Watch the trailer for I Am Not a Serial Killer here:

More in Film festivals

“It’s really complicated. It’s really hard if you put yourself in his shoes”: Nawaf Al Dhufairi, Raghad Bokhari and Lana Komsany on Hijra at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“Why didn’t I raise my voice for the Rohingya people?”: Akio Fujimoto on Lost Land at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“When you live with someone with a harsh mental illness, you can really sink with them”: Zain Duraie and Alaa Alasad on Sink at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

Red Sea International Film Festival 2025: Highlights and interviews with Juliette Binoche, Shigeru Umebayashi, Sir Anthony Hopkins, Idris Elba, and More

Laura Della Corte

“Modern love – it’s a bit dark”: Anas Ba Tahaf and Sarah Taibah on A Matter of Life and Death at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“I believe inside each human being there is an artist”: Mohamed Jabarah Al-Daradji, Hussein Raad Zuwayr and Samar Kazem Jawad on Irkalla – Gilgamesh Dream

Laura Della Corte

“When you try to forget the trauma without fixing it, it will never leave”: Yanis Koussim on Roqia at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“Is he dreaming? Is it real?”: Shahram Mokri and Nasim Ahmadpour on Black Rabbit, White Rabbit at Red Sea Interntional Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“Blending humour with tragedy is always a very Egyptian trait”: Abu Bakr Shawky on The Stories at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte