Film festivals Venice Film Festival 2019

An Officer and a Spy (J’Accuse)

Venice Film Festival 2019: An Officer and a Spy (J’Accuse) | Review

Eight years after the success of Carnage, celebrated auteur Roman Polanski returns to the Venice Film Festival with a historical drama revolving around the Dreyfus affair, one of the most influential socio-political events of the late 19th to early 20th century.

The Polish director delivers a masterfully crafted reconstruction of Paris 1894. Louis Garrel is exquisite in his portrayal of Jewish officer Alfred Dreyfus, who is accused of and convicted of treason. However, it’s Jean Dujardin who steals the scene as Georges Picquart, the head of secret services who investigates the wrongdoing within the military and seeks a re-trial.

Despite exceeding two hours, the pace of J’Accuse never misses a beat thanks to Robert Harris’s screenplay – based on his own novel – which delivers a beautiful combination of historical details and gripping storytelling. The film is set in another era but the universal nature of this miscarriage of justice makes it relevant in our day and age – and incredibly interesting to follow.

If Polanski’s movie is so fascinating, it’s also thanks to the entire technical assemble. Pawel Edelman’s cinematography is superb, with visuals that are capable of pleasing old-school critics as well as viewers who tend to rely on over-polished mainstream cinema. Alexandre Desplat’s trademark climatic score helps understand the relevance of this event as well as the personal drama of Dreyfus.

The ageing director hasn’t lost his touch; hopefully we’ll see a few more works of his in the next decade.

Filippo L’Astorina, the Editor

An Officer and a Spy (J’Accuse) does not have a release date yet.

Watch a clip fromAn Officer and a Spy (J’Accuse) here:

More in Film festivals

“It’s really complicated. It’s really hard if you put yourself in his shoes”: Nawaf Al Dhufairi, Raghad Bokhari and Lana Komsany on Hijra at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“Why didn’t I raise my voice for the Rohingya people?”: Akio Fujimoto on Lost Land at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“When you live with someone with a harsh mental illness, you can really sink with them”: Zain Duraie and Alaa Alasad on Sink at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“It felt quite absurd to be part of that social jungle”: Sara Balghonaim on Irtizaz at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

Red Sea International Film Festival 2025: Highlights and interviews with Juliette Binoche, Shigeru Umebayashi, Sir Anthony Hopkins, Idris Elba, and More

Laura Della Corte

“All that matters, I think, is the partnership”: Amira Diab on Wedding Rehearsal at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“I believe inside each human being there is an artist”: Mohamed Jabarah Al-Daradji, Hussein Raad Zuwayr and Samar Kazem Jawad on Irkalla – Gilgamesh Dream

Laura Della Corte

“When you try to forget the trauma without fixing it, it will never leave”: Yanis Koussim on Roqia at Red Sea International Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte

“Is he dreaming? Is it real?”: Shahram Mokri and Nasim Ahmadpour on Black Rabbit, White Rabbit at Red Sea Interntional Film Festival 2025

Laura Della Corte