Culture Music Album reviews

Moon Panda – Dumb Luck

Moon Panda – Dumb Luck | Album review

Moon Panda’s earliest work may feel like a reflection of their Californian roots: surf-rock elements, dreamy pop melodies and an eclectic ease define their 2019 EP Plastic Pool. On their newest project, Dumb Luck, those qualities remain, but the band broadens its palette, stretching into new techniques. Each track experiments with instrumentation and production in its own way, yet together they form a cohesive, atmospheric whole that feels like a natural evolution from their beginnings.

The album opens with Lost World, a bright and airy single that channels the summer months. Its soft rock foundation is warped by electronic touches, giving the track a hypnotic, almost tidal quality that sets up the rest of the album excellently. The psychedelic streak of their sophomore record, Sing Spaceship, Sing! still lingers here, though Dumb Luck leans more vintage and jazzy. That shift feels like growth rather than a departure. Fantasy is a standout example: lyrically, lead singer Maddy Myers dreams of escaping worldly troubles with a loved one, while musically the tune moves like a kaleidoscopic trip through psychedelic rock and airy alternative pop. 

Singles like Butterknife, Superstore and Penny highlight the band’s range on Dumb Luck. Butterknife pulls from surf rock and dream pop, Superstore blends mainstream sensibilities with 90s-inspired haze, and Penny ties both styles together, adding a nod to acid-rock influences as heard prior. Each feels distinct, yet they all contribute to the record’s exploratory spirit.

Still, the album’s cohesion can be a double-edged sword. Its consistently relaxed tempo, paired with Myers’s hypnotic vocals, risks blurring some moments together. Songs like Avalanche, despite being strong on their own, lose impact when surrounded by similarly paced arrangements. By the time The Light, one of Dumb Luck’s best productions, rolls around, casual listeners may find themselves drifting too deep into the dreaminess of this mystic soundscape.

Despite these pacing lulls, Dumb Luck is a worthy addition to Moon Panda’s discography. It captures their willingness to experiment while reviving the intimacy of 90s bedroom pop, enriched with the psychedelic hues they loved to implement on Sing Spaceship, Sing!. At  times, it may feel almost too seamless, but that continuity showcases the band’s vision of being genuine, immersive and quietly bold.

Taryn Crowley
Image: Ricky Bantog

Dumb Luck is released on 26th September 2025. For further information or to order the album, visit Moon Panda’s website here.

Watch the video for Lost World here:

More in Album reviews

Djo – The Crux Deluxe

Antigoni Pitta

Ed Sheeran – Play

Taryn Crowley

Curtis Harding – Departures & Arrivals: Adventures of Captain Curt

Sunny Morgan

CMAT – Euro-Country

Antonia Georgiou

Sabrina Carpenter – Man’s Best Friend

Mae Trumata

Wolf Alice – The Clearing

Christopher Connor

Big Noble – It’s Later Than You Think

Mark Worgan

Jack Garratt – Pillars

Ben Browning

Alison Goldfrapp – Flux

Emily Downie