TheatreMusical reviews

Sylvia at Royal Albert Hall

Despite the enormity of the auditorium at the Royal Albert Hall, Naomi Katiyo and Beverley Knight effortlessly fill the space with their velvety vocals

By Emilia Gould

Share this story

Sylvia at Royal Albert Hall | Theatre review

Sylvia at Royal Albert Hall
Sylvia at Royal Albert Hall

With the tagline: “A Musical Revolution,” one would expect Sylvia to have an incredibly disruptive script and unforgettable score, yet this production delivers a story that shaped the 20th century in a largely unimaginative and unaffecting way.

Sylvia tells the tale of Sylvia Pankhurst, a major figure in the Suffragette movement who particularly championed the rights of working women. This musical firmly falls victim to the Lin-Manuel Miranda-fication of theatre. Each song is sung through with a patter that can’t decide if it is speech, rap or slam poetry. Lines that would perhaps have some poignancy if delivered with clear acting choices are sacrificed at the altar of sounding like a Hamilton off-cut. It is difficult to differentiate one number from the next, with each act blending into one fairly monotonous hum.

A reminder about the significance of the Suffragette movement feels incredibly important in an era when “looksmaxxing” and “trad wives” fill our social media feeds, but it feels patronising to young people to purvey the story through a script peppered with anachronisms such as “bro”, “sis” and “mansplaining”. The choice to modernise Sylvia’s life story feels unwarranted, given how relatively recently it occurred, and how much it continues to affect all of our lives today.

Throughout the production, the entire movement is painted facetiously – in one moment a male ensemble character laments: “Oh my goodness, that wench is the worst,” an insult that does not feel large enough to stir up sufficient anger to start a revolution. It feels as though the creative team was too timid to show the true harshness of life for women pre-suffrage; the result is a protest in which the stakes feel very low, compared to the hardships the Suffragettes faced and the vast sacrifices they subsequently made. Moments of togetherness also lack weight and come across as saccharine rather than unifying.

That being said, the cast is made up of exceptional performers. Despite the enormity of the auditorium at the Royal Albert Hall, Naomi Katiyo (Sylvia) and Beverley Knight (Emmeline) effortlessly fill the space with their velvety vocals. The entire ensemble executes choreography with muscularity and strength – the dance does much more to demonstrate the emotions of the characters than the script itself.

Sylvia has all the makings of a fantastic musical – dynamic dance numbers, powerhouse vocals, slick harmonies – but is not brave enough to really make an impact. Despite the talented cast, the production lacks the passion that the story of this canonical movement deserves.

Emilia Gould
Photos: Tristram Kenton

Sylvia is at Royal Albert Hall until 15th November 2026. For further information or to book, visit the theatre’s website here.