Culture Cinema & Tv Show reviews

The Castaways

The Castaways | Show review

Sheridan Smith and Celine Buckens lead the cast in this glossy Paramount+ series based on the popular book by Lucy Clarke. A plane carrying 14 people crashes into the Pacific Ocean without any explanation as to why or where it is, and with no bodies recovered. Smith plays the unlucky plane crash victim Lori Holme, while Buckens portrays her wayward sister Erin. Both sisters were meant to be on the plane, however, they argue the night before, which leads to Erin missing the flight and Lori flying solo, leaving Erin desperately searching for answers.

Buckens plays the rebellious and relentless Erin very well, and Smith is fantastically watchable as always, but some of the surrounding characters are unconvincing, and there’s some pretty wooden acting in places. The ex-husband of Lori and his new partner are unreasonably belittling towards Erin while she tries to investigate what happened to the plane, telling her she needs to move on and eventually kicking her out despite it only being months after the plane disappeared. As is usually the case with these types of series, Erin is having a hard time convincing everyone else that there’s something fishy going on.

While she scrambles around Fiji searching for answers on the whereabouts of her sister, we get to see what Lori’s up to with the rest of the plane crash survivors on the island. But is there more to the story than just a simple accident?

There are a few tweaks here and there where the book adaption is concerned and the storyline gets crazier with each episode, but if you don’t mind a completely implausible plot and are just after a fun, easy-to-digest deserted island series then The Castaways might be for you. It’s slickly shot, with plenty of aspirational content, and Smith and Buckens carry it well, even when the script verges on cringeworthy.

Hannah Broughton

The Castaways is released on Paramount+ on 26th December 2023.

Watch the trailer for The Castaways here:

More in Shows

Oh. What. Fun.

Constance Ayrton

Dreamers

Andrew Murray

Tinsel Town: Robbie Williams, Alice Eve, Ray Fearon, Katherine Ryan, Rebel Wilson, Matilda Firth and Ava Aashna Chopra at the London premiere

Sarah Bradbury

Stranger Things season five, volume one

Andrew Murray

“I always like painting on the two-hour canvas”: David Michôd on Christy

Selina Sondermann

Nicole Kidman and Jamie Lee Curtis bring Patricia Cornwell’s forensic icon to life in Prime Video’s Scarpetta

The editorial unit

Sean Combs: The Reckoning – Explosive four-part documentary lands on Netflix this December

The editorial unit

Kristen Stewart steps behind the camera for powerful debut The Chronology of Water, in cinemas February 2026

The editorial unit

Joanna Lumley, Richard Curtis and Beatles family attend exclusive screening of The Beatles Anthology at BFI Southbank

The editorial unit